Islam, democracy, and constitutional liberalism islam, democracy, and constitutional liberalism zakaria, fareed 20040301 00. Further, our work lays the foundation for a research agenda investigating of the relationship between political islam and democracy. It is not merely the explicit merger or clash of the two ideologies that provides the basis for liberalism to promote or undermine democracy, as the case may be. It differs from liberal democracy in that it is not about the method of selecting government. This paper proposes a short apprehension of the reflections of one of the most important progressive islamic scholars, the egyptian theologian ali abderraziq. The arab rulers of the middle east are autocratic, corrupt, and heavyhanded. Whats the difference between an islamic state and secular. The third issue is the source of law, it incongruently being fully secular in ideal democracy but partially divine in religions. Liberalism is suffering but democracy is doing just fine. The modern idea of a state as we see todaywhether it is progressivism, liberalism, democracythis is a postworld war ii construct.
Some cornerstones of these issues are freedom of assembly and speech, inclusiveness and equality. Beyond liberal democracy national chengchi university. Liberalism as it is understood here corresponds to the. The distinction between the two variants of liberalism, preference based and outcome based, has been discussed by many authors. Fareed zakaria has published articles on democracy and islam in scholarly journals. Within western liberal democracies, academic inquiry has identi. Islam in liberalism, massad university of chicago press.
On a normative level, if the pursuit of constitutional islamization is indeed shown to be in. Many have put forward the example of turkey as the most successful implementation of what islam can entail in a secular democratic polity. Brown a period of global experimentation with, and enthusiasm about, constitu. Contents v list of tables and figures vii preface ix 1 islam and democracy. It focuses on his work about islam and the fundamentals of power, published in 1925. This article analyzes the effects of democracy on religious political parties. Dec 12, 2011 muslims are not betraying islam in embracing liberal democracy. Sometimes called developmental democracy can be used to advance civil libertiesparticipation 5. Either liberal constitutionalism must choose justice over democracy, or choose democracy over justice. Critically examines the concepts of democracy and liberalism provides a brief introduction to the australian political system shows the ways in which democracy and liberalism interact in our political system. The rule of law, islam, and constitutional politics in.
However, this is where the similarity between the islamic system and. Democracy and the dynamics of secularism 35 3 malaysia. Constitutional liberalism, on the other hand, is not about the procedures for selecting government, but rather governments goals. Two important values 153 institutionalizing confucian democracy 162 7. Liberalism and social action by john dewey new york. Under the restored constitution the ottoman empire had become a constitutional monarchy, and the speech that the sultan presented, britishstyle, to. The third issue is the source of law, it incongruently being fully secular in ideal democracy but. Does liberalism promote or undermine democracy politics essay. This is an essential part of any functioning democracy. Islam, liberalism, and democracy the journal of scriptural. Sample only oxford university press anz democracy and. Within islamist movements, liberal islamists are almost nonexistent.
And practice of course, in a certain context, is seen as a product of politics and culture. The journalist and scholar fareed zakaria explains that constitutional liberalism is about governments goals. Many americans are not aware that liberalism is a welldefined political ideology that was the dominant ideology of the ruling capitalist class in the west for nearly 200 years. I appreciate russell hardins levelheaded, nononsense analysis towards political theory in liberalism, constitutionalism, and democracy. Mark blyth on how liberalism undermined democracy and the. It calls for the freedoms that are stated in americas first amendmentfreedom of press, speech, religion, and assembly. Muslims are not betraying islam in embracing liberal democracy. Pdf soft constitutional law in nonliberal asian constitutional. Under the restored constitution the ottoman empire had become a constitutional monarchy, and the speech that the sultan presented, britishstyle, to his parliament. In 1215, english nobles pressured king john of england to sign a document known as the magna carta, a key step on the road to constitutional democracy. The uncertainty of outcomes is inherent in democracy. Islam in liberalism is a timely and important book to read, particularly as it urges us to continue to reflect in new ways not only on the prevalent imperial order, intellectual and militaristic, of spreading and securing democracy and freedom but also on how islam persistently is referenced and used in western countries and in liberal.
These nations had advanced industrial economies, sizable middle classes, and high literacy ratesfactors that many political scientists regarded as prerequisites for successful democracy. Democracy with confucian characteristics 152 political elitism and democracy. Liberal democracy is a form of government that operates under a constitutional system and is ruled by the electorate. Constitutional democracy refers here to the employment of democracy for debating and validating the constitution including the constitution of the democratic process itself. The story of indian democracy 37 different groups of people representing competing interest and often also different political parties. This paper examines the nexus of constitutionalism and democracy. In particular, hardin ably pokes holes in the commonbutuseless analogy between constitutions and social contracts. The tension that is often seen to exist between the ideals of liberalism and of democracy is examined in this paper in light of the distinction between two liberal outlooks at constitutional regimes, namely, on the one side, a liberal constitutionalism that focuses on the need to provide institutional safeguards of individual liberty as private autonomy and, on the. So democracy is not a western import but a core part of muslim history. By doing so, the king acknowledged he was bound by law. Islam, democracy, and constitutional liberalism, political. Nov 28, 2012 democracy also endorsed on the grounds that political participation has educational advantages by participating in political life citizens enhance their understanding and achieve a higher level of personal development.
It refers to the tradition, deep in western history, that seeks to protect an individuals autonomy and dignity against coercion, whatever the source. Constitutionalism will not disappear, but it will find itself grappling with. Liberal constitutionalism, constitutional liberalism and. Constitutional democracy in a multicultural and globalised world. Issues in the conservation of photographs, it gesttztes lernen wissensmanagement, and many other ebooks. Party fp fazilet partisi, which the constitutional court shut down in 2001 for being.
The crisis of secular liberalism and the constitutional state in. The third part of this chapter seeks to discuss how competing interests function, what the ter ms inter est gr oups and political parties mean and what. Islam, democracy, and constitutional liberalism article in political science quarterly 1191. We also have many ebooks and user guide is also related with islamic liberalism a critique of development ideologies pdf, include. Fareed zakarias islam, democracy, and constitutional. Leaving aside the polemical and apologetic argumentsthat islam, not western liberalism, is the true democracy, or that western liberalism itself derives from islamic rootsthe debate about. Democracy and liberalism in australia this chapter. In an islamic state, the leader caliph is appointed by the muslim ummah through a process of consultation shura, whether it is direct plebiscite of the people or election by a council of representatives e. Less than a quartercentury ago, democracy appeared to be confined, with a few exceptions, to north america and western europe.
Islam, democracy, and constitutional liberalism zakaria 2004. Zakaria is now editor of newsweek international and a columnist for newsweek. Abdulkarim soroush argues that to appreciate the significance of the concept of islamic democracy, we need to decouple liberalism and democracy. Benhenda, mostapha, liberal democracy and political islam. See also david estlund, democracy and the real speech situtation, in d eliberative d emocracy and i ts d iscontents s. The rule of law is not an arid legal doctrine but is the foundations of a fair and just. Dec 31, 2016 the tension between liberalism and democracy has become far sharper. Liberalism, religion, and the unity of epistemology, 30 san diego l. Fareed zakaria reflects on the factors present in the middle east that have provided for the rise of islamic fundamentalism and a complete absence of democracy. The populist challenge to liberal democracy beagle and wolf. Liberalism and democracyon what grounds have liberals defended democracy. The tension between liberalism and democracy has become far sharper. Zakaria, islam, democracy, and constitutional liberalism, p.
Constitutional democracy in a multicultural and globalised. The fair treatment would be that religion is compared to religions. Constitutional liberalism describes a form of government that upholds the principles of classical liberalism and the rule of law. It is quite separate from the popular notion of liberalism which is essentially a vague attitude of lets all try to get along and be nice to each other. The correlation between liberalism and democracy has been one where liberalism has both strengthened and destabilized democracy at different times, in different ways. Democracy is a system of processing conflicts in which outcomes depend on what participants do, but no single force controls what occurs and its outcomes. Many liberals insist that the only way of defending liberal values is by insulating them from the democratic process. Zakaria starts with explaining the dilemma of autocratic states versus illiberal societies in middle eastern countries. Background for discussion in 2001, freedom house included indonesia as a free country, although the rate of indonesias civil liberties is placed lower than the political rights.
Nozick 12 criticized sens preferencebasedliberalism. Politicized islam in a debilitated democracy 151 6 mali. Islam and nationalism in a semidemocratic state 83 4 pakistan. Fareed zakaria, a well known indian origined american writer, who is the editor of international newsweek magazine and columnist in the washington post journal, talks about the problems of middle eastern countries in his article islam, democracy, and constitutional liberalism. The rule of law, islam, and constitutional politics in egypt. Mergers and takeovers and property ownership guidelines for the. Democracy makes all forces struggle repeatedly to realize their interests and devolves power from groups of people to sets of rules. It also explores the literature on the other side,which posits the asian success as a refutation of the. Illiberal democracy at home and abroad, is being translated into fifteen languages. The government is representative of the people and regular elections are held. Who people are and how authority is shared among them are core issues for democratic theory, development and constitution. Page 19 to have democracy mean, subjectively, a good government renders it analytically useless. The populist threat to liberal democracy was published by yale. Sep 21, 2009 benhenda, mostapha, liberal democracy and political islam.
But that question should not override the issue, already a significant one in european countries, especially in britain, of whether islamic sharia law is compatible with a democratic legal system. Theoretical reflections on religious freedom issue in indonesia novriantoni kahar dosen universitas paramadina, jakarta 2. Democracy brought together four prominent muslim americans who represent a range of progressive political viewpoints to ask them about the progressive roots of islam, how the religion might revive those more liberal traditions, the extent to which muslims and nonmuslims should criticize islam, and more. Pdf as constitutional texts are incomplete guides to actual practice, the. Islam and democracy muslim world residents see no conflict between religious principles and democratic values by dalia mogahed, executive director, the gallup center for muslim studies islam in politics has been asserted in many countries in the muslim world through democratic elections. Persatuan alumni universiti malaya paum registration starts at 8 a.
The rule of law, islam, and constitutional politics in egypt and iran said amir arjomand and nathan j. Pdf could populism be good for constitutional democracy. The story of indian democracy 3 social change and development in india 36 w e are all familiar with the idea that democracy is a government of the people, by the people, and for the people. Is democracy the least bad system for minority groups. Democracy, security, and religious political parties. Accordingly, constitutional democracies are typically governed according to two sets of principles.
796 12 1591 525 1122 1515 115 195 1261 1185 946 351 1174 1513 526 1482 1396 679 974 618 1568 447 1420 257 965 773 1400 125 1299 490 1098 1450 1310 482